Insurance Advisor - Personal Lines

Baldwin Group Colleague, Inc.; United States; Hybrid; USD 45,000 - 55,000; Full time

Job summary

The Baldwin Group is seeking a driven insurance sales professional to manage leads, present proposals, and close new business with clients across the U.S. You will coordinate with carriers and the service team to ensure smooth onboarding.

Base salary starts at $50,000 annually with monthly commissions and performance bonuses, plus equity opportunities for high performers. Hybrid/remote work is allowed with occasional in-person meetings.

Qualifications

• Active Property & Casualty License required.
• Minimum of 2 years personal lines insurance experience.
• Proven sales track record and meeting production goals.
• Strong communication skills, both verbal and written.
• Ability to manage high call volumes and pipelines.

Responsibilities

• Manage company-provided leads and pursue cross-sell opportunities.
• Present insurance proposals and ensure client understanding.
• Cultivate client relationships to drive referrals and retention.
• Follow up with clients via phone, email, and virtual meetings.
• Close sales and transition to service team with complete docs.
• Maintain accurate records and pipeline in CRM.

Skills

Phone sales

Relationship-building

Communication

Time management

Organization

Self-motivated

Team collaboration

Tools

CRM systems

Agency management platforms

Email

Video conferencing

Job description

The Baldwin Group is an award-winning entrepreneur-led and inspired insurance brokerage firm delivering expertly crafted Commercial Insurance and Risk Management, Private Insurance and Risk Management, Employee Benefits and Benefit Administration, Asset and Income Protection, and Risk Mitigation strategies to clients wherever their passions and businesses take them throughout the U.S. and abroad. The Baldwin Group has award-winning industry expertise, colleagues, competencies, insurers, and most importantly, a highly differentiated culture that our clients consider an invaluable expansion of their business. The Baldwin Group (NASDAQ: BWIN), takes a holistic and tailored approach to insurance and risk management. **Will consider hybrid/remote with the right experience BUT must be able to attend a monthly sales meeting in Kingston, MA office**

Responsibilities

• Manage company-provided leads while identifying cross-sell and upsell opportunities to drive business growth.
• Generate referrals and cultivate long-term client relationships through centers of influence and strategic referral partnerships.
• Present insurance proposals in a professional and consultative manner, reviewing coverages in detail to ensure client understanding and confidence in recommended solutions.
• Communicates effectively and professionally with clients, prospects, insurance company partners, and internal service team members through phone, email, and virtual meetings.
• Finalizes sales by collecting required documentation, applications, and signatures while ensuring a seamless transition to the service team.
• Builds trust quickly with prospective clients by identifying needs, overcoming objections, and providing tailored insurance solutions.
• Maintains strong follow-up discipline and pipeline management to maximize conversion opportunities and client retention.
• Prepares recommendations and coverage solutions for prospective accounts while adhering to agency policies and carrier underwriting guidelines.
• Maintains a high level of accuracy, organization, and attention to detail in all client and carrier interactions to minimize errors and omissions exposure.
• Maintains current knowledge of insurance products, industry trends, and underwriting guidelines for carrier partners represented by the firm.
• Represents the firm professionally within the community and in all interactions with clients and insurance company partners.
• Identifies opportunities to improve workflow, processes, and overall business performance while contributing positively to team culture.
• Meets or exceeds monthly new business production goals and performance expectations.
• Performs additional duties and responsibilities as assigned by leadership.

Compensation & Growth Opportunity

• Base salary starting at $50,000 annually.
• Monthly commission opportunities with uncapped earning potential.
• Performance-based bonus opportunities.
• Equity and long-term growth opportunities available for high performers.
• Opportunity to grow within a fast-paced, relationship-driven organization focused on professional development and career advancement.

Requirements

• Active Property & Casualty License required.
• Minimum of 2 years of personal lines insurance experience required.
• Proven sales background with a track record of meeting or exceeding production goals.
• Strong phone sales and relationship-building skills with the ability to confidently lead conversations and close business.
• Excellent verbal and written communication skills.
• Strong emotional intelligence and the ability to build rapport quickly with a wide range of personalities.
• Comfortable handling high call volume, follow-up activity, and pipeline management in a fast-paced environment.
• Strong technical and computer skills, including proficiency with CRM systems, agency management platforms, email, and virtual communication tools.
• Highly organized with strong attention to detail and time management skills.
• Self-motivated, competitive, coachable, and goal-oriented mindset.
• Ability to work independently while also contributing positively within a team environment.

#LI-KL1 IMPORTANT NOTICE: This position description is intended to describe the level of work required of the person performing in the role and is not a contract. The essential responsibilities are outlined; other duties may be assigned as needs arise or as required to support the organization. All requirements may be subject to reasonable accommodation to applicants and colleagues who need them for medical or religious reasons.

The Baldwin Group will not accept unsolicited resumes from any source other than directly from a candidate who applies on our career site. Any unsolicited resumes sent to The Baldwin Group, including unsolicited resumes sent via any source from an Agency, will not be considered and are not subject to any fees for any placement resulting from the receipt of an unsolicited resume. The Baldwin Group is a cohesive group of experts in business insurance, employee benefits, retirement planning, and all areas of private and personal insurance. Since 2011, we’ve evolved from a local business into a national firm with a vast network of specializations serving two million clients across the country. At The Baldwin Group, we provide solutions so our clients can pursue what’s possible for themselves, their families, and their businesses. Whether renting a first apartment, opening a small business or taking a company public, we offer solutions to support clients at every step of their journey giving them peace of mind to pursue their purpose, passion, and dreams. We Protect the Possible. The Baldwin Group is an equal employment opportunity firm and strives to comply with all laws prohibiting discrimination based on race, color, religion, age, sex (including sexual orientation and gender identity), national origin or ancestry, disability, military status, marital status, and any other category protected by federal, state, or local laws. All such discrimination is unlawful, and all persons involved in the operations of the firm are prohibited from engaging in this conduct.