High School Theology Teacher

Catholic Schools in the Archdiocese of New York; New York (NY); On-site; USD 55,000 - 65,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Full benefits program

Opportunities for professional growth

Job summary

Cardinal Hayes High School invites applications for a full-time Theology teaching role for the 2026-2027 school year. The school seeks candidates passionate about creating rigorous, high-expectation, supportive classroom cultures and welcomes uncertified teachers at early career stages.

A bachelor’s degree is required and background checks will be conducted. The position emphasizes teaching Theology to high school students, with collaboration on curriculum and assignments, and a commitment to

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Theology or Education required; graduate degree preferred.
• State teaching certification in the relevant field preferred.
• Experience working with high school students preferred; strong classroom management.

Responsibilities

• Teach Theology at the high school level.
• Design innovative, engaging, and differentiated high school lessons.
• Plan assignments and curriculum in collaboration with other departments.
• Work one-on-one with students daily for support and enrichment.
• Complete administrative and supervisory duties as assigned.
• Support the mission of Cardinal Hayes High School.

Skills

Classroom management

Collaborative teaching

Bilingual (preferred)

Education

Bachelor's degree in Theology or Education

Job description

For over 80 years, Cardinal Hayes High School has been working as a college-preparatory institution to educate young men of the New York City metropolitan area, encouraging the development and expression of their unique talents to prepare students for post-secondary education and life. Our legacy of success in helping our young men achieve extraordinary things in college and beyond is well-documented, with tremendous 4-year graduation and college-placement rates serving as the norm, rather than exceptions to the general rule. More importantly for us, however, encouraging students to achieve the high standard of becoming "Hayesmen" over the course of their four years at the "Hayes House" is the passion of a dedicated community of faculty, staff, administration, trustees, alumni, parents/guardians, and students. We invite you to apply to join this focused community as a teacher of Theology for the school year 2026-2027.

We are seeking candidates with passion for science and for creating rigorous, high-expectation, supportive, and welcoming classroom cultures. While prior teaching experience and subject-area certification are important to us, we also enthusiastically welcome uncertified teachers at the very beginnings of their careers to apply. Enthusiasm, energy, resiliency, patience, intelligence, and dedication are far more important to us than are prior experience and certification.

Candidates must have a minimum of a bachelor's degree and be fully authorized to work in the United States for any employer in order to have their applications considered. They should also be aware that they must submit to a background check prior to having employment confirmed.

Cardinal Hayes High School is an equal opportunity employer and actively encourages applications from people of all backgrounds. Compensation is competitive and commensurate with experience and certification. Cardinal Hayes High School offers a full benefits program and opportunities for professional growth.

We look forward to reviewing your application materials and thank you for your interest in Cardinal Hayes High School.

Job Type: Full-time

Essential Duties and Responsibilities

• Teach Theology at the high school level

• Design innovative, engaging, and differentiated high school lessons
• Plan assignments and curriculum in collaboration with science teachers and other departments
• Work one-on-one with students daily for support and enrichment
• Complete administrative and supervisory duties as assigned
• Support the mission of Cardinal Hayes High School

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Theology or in Education required; graduate degree preferred

• State teaching certification in the relevant field preferred
• Experience working with high school students preferred
• Strong classroom management abilities
• Ability to work productively and collaboratively with a diverse faculty and student body
• A belief that all students can succeed
• Open-minded, flexible, and adaptable
• Excellent oral and written communication skills
• Bilingual preferred, but not required

Work Remotely

• No

Salary

• 55k to 65k per year