Head of Talent

Garage

New York (NY)

On-site

USD 180,000 - 260,000

Full time

3 days ago
Be an early applicant

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Stock options
Medical, dental and vision insurance
Unlimited PTO
Meals in NYC
Wellness stipend
401(k) with employer match
Pre-tax commuter benefits
Annual team offsite
Relocation assistance

Job summary

Garage is seeking a Head of Talent in NYC to build and own the recruiting function as the company scales. You will partner with the CEO and leadership to attract exceptional engineering, growth, marketing, operations, and corporate talent, and to implement scalable recruiting systems.

This hands-on leadership role requires closing top candidates and shaping an employer brand in a competitive market. You will design strategy, lead high-priority searches, track KPIs, and grow a world-class team

Qualifications

  • 8+ years of recruiting experience, including owning talent acquisition strategy.
  • Experience building or scaling recruiting at a high-growth, venture-backed startup.
  • Proven track record recruiting and closing exceptional talent across multiple functions (technical & GTM).
  • Experience partnering directly with founders and senior executives on hiring strategy and workforce planning.
  • Strong understanding of the NYC talent market and in-office teams.
  • Familiar with modern recruiting tools and ATS like Ashby.

Responsibilities

  • Own Garage's end-to-end talent acquisition strategy, partnering with leaders on hiring priorities and headcount planning.
  • Lead full-cycle recruiting for senior roles, sourcing, assessing, and closing candidates.
  • Build and lead Garage's internal recruiting function and develop a high-performing team.
  • Design scalable recruiting processes and infrastructure to enable rapid hiring while maintaining a high talent bar.
  • Establish and track recruiting KPIs to improve funnel performance and hiring velocity.
  • Build Garage's employer brand and craft a differentiated candidate experience.

Skills

Recruiting leadership
Executive partnering
People management
Data-driven decisions

Tools

Ashby ATS

Job description

About Us

Our vision is to become the marketplace for everything expensive, specialized, and difficult to move. We’re building the infrastructure that powers the procurement and disposition of assets across America’s essential industries, automating everything from discovery and payments to freight, warranty, and financing. Today, Garage operates in cities and towns across all 50 states and has surpassed $100M+ in annualized transaction volume on the platform.

Our mission is to save local governments and essential services businesses time and money. We started with fire departments two years ago and have since expanded into EMS and heavy-duty, launching new verticals while growing revenue >10x last year.

If you move fast, hold a high bar, and want meaningful ownership in building a category-defining company, Garage is the place to do it.

About the Role

As the Head of Talent, you will own and build the recruiting function behind Garage’s next stage of growth. You'll partner closely with the CEO and leadership team to attract exceptional talent across engineering, growth, marketing, operations, and corporate functions, helping us scale rapidly without compromising on our talent bar.

This is a hands-on leadership role for someone who is equally excited about closing exceptional candidates as they are about building a world-class recruiting organization. You'll set the talent acquisition strategy, own high-priority searches, build scalable recruiting systems, and ultimately grow and lead the team responsible for bringing Garage's next generation of talent on board.

  • Own Garage's end-to-end talent acquisition strategy, partnering directly with the Chief of Staff and functional leaders on hiring priorities, headcount planning, and execution.

  • Lead full-cycle recruiting for critical and senior-level roles, personally sourcing, assessing, and closing exceptional candidates.

  • Build and lead Garage's internal recruiting function, hiring and developing a high-performing team as the company scales.

  • Design scalable recruiting processes, systems, and infrastructure that enable rapid hiring while maintaining an exceptionally high talent bar.

  • Establish and track recruiting KPIs, leveraging data to improve funnel performance, hiring velocity, candidate quality, and overall recruiting effectiveness.

  • Build Garage's employer brand and create a differentiated candidate experience that attracts the best talent in a competitive market.

Who You Are
  • Builder mentality. Excited to build a recruiting function from the ground up, with the ability to operate strategically while remaining deeply hands-on.

  • Exceptional talent judgment. Has an instinct for identifying outstanding people and a relentless commitment to raising the talent bar.

  • Strong operator. Highly analytical, organized, and process-oriented, with the ability to translate ambitious hiring goals into clear plans and measurable results.

  • Compelling recruiter and closer. Knows how to engage top talent, build meaningful relationships, and get exceptional candidates excited about joining Garage.

  • High ownership and bias toward action. Thrives in fast-paced, ambiguous environments, moves with urgency, and takes personal accountability for outcomes.

  • Trusted leadership partner. Able to influence executives, challenge assumptions, and provide thoughtful guidance on hiring decisions and organizational growth.

What You'll Need
  • 8+ years of recruiting experience, including experience owning talent acquisition strategy and leading recruiting teams.

  • Experience building or scaling recruiting at a high-growth, venture-backed startup, ideally through periods of significant headcount expansion.

  • Proven track record of recruiting and closing exceptional talent across multiple functions, including technical and GTM roles.

  • Experience partnering directly with founders and senior executives on hiring strategy, workforce planning, and critical searches.

  • Strong understanding of the NYC talent market, with an established network and experience recruiting for in-office teams.

  • Deep familiarity with modern recruiting tools, sourcing platforms, and applicant tracking systems such as Ashby.

Our Values

  • Take Big Swings. We are here to transform an overlooked industry—not make small improvements around the edges. We set ambitious goals, take calculated risks, and push through setbacks. We never trade lasting impact for short-term comfort.

  • Customers Come First. Our customers operate in an industry burdened by slow, expensive, and outdated processes. We attack the problems that cost them the most and measure our success by the time and money we give back to them.

  • Play For the Front of the Jersey. We put the mission ahead of ourselves. We challenge each other directly, support each other relentlessly, and step up whenever the team needs us. We win together, and we have fun doing it.

  • All Gas, No Ego. Building something that matters takes relentless effort. We move fast, take ownership, and see hard problems through. When we fall short, we own it, learn quickly, and come back stronger.

Why Join Garage?

  • Do work that matters. Our platform helps people buy the assets that local communities rely on to keep their communities safe, clean, and operating every day.

  • Help shape the company. Join as one of our first 50 employees and work directly alongside the founders.

  • Make an outsized impact. You’ll join a talent-dense, high-performance team where every person moves the company forward.

  • Build from a strong foundation. We’ve raised $60M to date, including a $41M Series B, from Y Combinator, Initialized Capital, Infinity Ventures, FJ Labs, and other leading investors.

What We Offer

  • Competitive salary and stock options

  • 100% medical, dental and vision insurance coverage

  • Unlimited PTO (in addition to company observed holidays)

  • Daily lunch & dinner (for employees based in NYC)

  • $100/month wellness stipend

  • 401(k) w/ employer match

  • Pre-tax commuter benefits

  • Annual team offsite

  • Relocation assistance

We realize applying for jobs can feel daunting at times. We don’t expect you to check all the qualification boxes and encourage you to apply if you have experience in some of the areas.

Equal Opportunity

As an equal-opportunity employer, we are committed to building an inclusive environment where you can be you. We work hard to evaluate all employees and job applicants consistently, without regard to race, color, religion, gender, natural origin, age, disability, pregnancy, gender expression or identity, sexual orientation, or any other legally protected class.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

People Strategy & Operations — Scale Talent & Hiring
People Strategy & Operations — Scale Talent & Hiring

Benchstrength • New York (NY)

Hybrid
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Stock options
Health coverage
Unlimited PTO
+6
Founding Sales Development Representative (SDR)
Founding Sales Development Representative (SDR)

Benchstrength • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Stock options
Health insurance
Unlimited PTO
+6
Founding GTM Recruiter
Founding GTM Recruiter

Garage (YC W24) • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Salary & stock options
100% medical, dental and vision
Unlimited PTO
+6
Founding Technical Recruiter
Founding Technical Recruiter

Benchstrength • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Competitive salary
Stock options
Medical, dental, vision
+5
Software Engineer, Design
Software Engineer, Design

Garage • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Competitive salary
Stock options
Medical, dental and vision insurance
+5
Software Engineer, Growth
Software Engineer, Growth

Benchstrength • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Stock options
Full benefits
Unlimited PTO
+6
Growth Marketer
Growth Marketer

garage • United States

On-site
USD 70,000 - 120,000
Competitive salary
Stock options
Medical, dental and vision insurance
+7
People Strategy & Operations
People Strategy & Operations

Benchstrength • New York (NY)

Hybrid
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Stock options
Health coverage
Unlimited PTO
+6
People Strategy & Operations
People Strategy & Operations

Garage • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 85,000
Stock options
Full health coverage
Unlimited PTO
+6
Growth Marketer
Growth Marketer

Garage • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Competitive compensation
Stock options
Health insurance
+2