Director of Donor Relations

Timothy Christian

Elmhurst (IL)

On-site

USD 110,000 - 180,000

Full time

4 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Timothy Christian Schools in Elmhurst, IL seeks a Director of Donor Relations to build and steward major gifts, planned gifts, and sponsorships. The role involves personally cultivating relationships with donors, alumni, families, and partners, and coordinating with leadership and the Advancement team to advance the mission.

The Director will guide a portfolio of prospects, align giving with Timothy’s mission, and drive campaigns to support Christ-centered education for generations to come.

Qualifications

  • Exceptional interpersonal and communications skills with a donor-centric approach.
  • Experience building and managing donor portfolios and major gift solicitations.
  • Familiarity with CRM systems and data-driven donor stewardship.

Responsibilities

  • Build and actively manage a portfolio of current and prospective donors with a major gifts focus.
  • Cultivate, solicit, and steward major gifts, planned giving, and sponsorships.
  • Partner with leadership and Advancement teams to execute campaigns and stewardship.
  • Maintain CRM records and report pipeline, solicitations, and outcomes to leadership.

Skills

Interpersonal skills
Fundraising
Donor cultivation
CRM familiarity
Strategic thinking
Communication
Mission alignment

Education

Bachelor's degree in a relevant field

Tools

CRM software

Job description

Opportunity Profile: Director of Donor Relations

Inviting a gifted relationship-builder to inspire Team Timothy to invest in the mission of Timothy Christian Schools.

  • Start Date: July 1, 2027
  • Status: Full Time
  • Reports To: Executive Director of Strategic Engagement & Enrollment

Preschool - 12th Grade Biblically-Rooted Nondenominational 28-Acre Campus

About Timothy: A National Blue Ribbon Campus

Founded in 1911, Timothy Christian Schools is a Biblically-rooted, nondenominational school serving approximately 1,270 students from preschool through 12th grade on a 28-acre campus in south Elmhurst. For generations, teachers, coaches, and staff have helped students identify and nurture their God-given gifts—educating servant leaders who glorify God.

Timothy families worship at more than 200 area churches across Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox traditions, united by a shared commitment to Christ-centered, excellence-driven education.

At a glance

  • 1911: Year founded
  • 28: Acre campus in Elmhurst
  • 200+: Area churches represented

Our Mission
For the glory of God, Timothy Christian Schools exists to uphold Biblical truth, ignite academic growth, and inspire courageous leadership one student at a time.

Our Vision
Timothy Christian Schools will develop life-long learners and servant leaders who fully live out their purpose in the world for Christ.

Our Values
Christ-Centered Biblically-Rooted Excellence-Driven Growth-Oriented Relationship-Focused Individually-Customized Leadership-Minded Opportunity-Based Collaboratively-Supported

Accredited by Cognia Recognized by the Illinois State Board of Education Member, Council on Educational Standards & Accountability Timothy Christian High School: 2019 U.S. Department of Education National Blue Ribbon School

The Opportunity: Build relationships that advance Christ-centered education

At Timothy Christian Schools, generosity helps make the mission possible: upholding Biblical truth, igniting academic growth, and inspiring courageous leadership one student at a time. The Director of Donor Relations will invite others to invest in that mission by connecting their passions and resources with opportunities to make a lasting difference in students’ lives.

Timothy approaches this next chapter from a position of strength. Enrollment has reached record levels, and the school has invested $75 million in its campus over the past decade. The Timothy Foundation, established in 1978 with a $28,000 bequest, now holds more than $5.5 million supporting tuition assistance, faculty development, and new programs. Stack the WAC, a middle school addition that will introduce a 6-12 AI & STEM Center, broke ground in 2026.

The Director will build on this momentum by developing relationships with donors, alumni, grandparents, parents, business leaders, and friends of Timothy. This is an externally focused fundraising role with responsibility for personally cultivating, soliciting, and stewarding major gifts, planned gifts, and sponsorships.

Working alongside school leadership and supported by the Advancement team’s fundraising, hospitality, events, marketing, communications, and multimedia resources, the Director will spend most of their time connecting with people. The opportunity is to help supporters see how their generosity can strengthen Timothy today and sustain Christ-centered education for generations to come.

  • 75M: Invested in campus over the past decade
  • 5.5M+: Timothy Foundation assets
  • 115: Years of God’s faithfulness

The Donor Relationship Journey: how the Director guides every relationship

  • Awareness: Friends come to understand Timothy’s mission and story.
  • Consideration: They see where their passions meet Timothy’s priorities.
  • Conversion: A personal invitation to invest—and a yes.
  • Loyalty: Thoughtful stewardship keeps them engaged between gifts.
  • Advocacy: They champion Timothy and open doors to others.
Key Responsibilities

This is an externally focused position. The Director builds and actively manages a portfolio of current and prospective donors, with particular emphasis on major gifts, capital campaigns, sponsorships, and planned giving.

1. Donor Relationship Development

  • Build and manage a portfolio of current and prospective donors, with an intentional strategy and clear next steps for each.
  • Develop authentic, long-term relationships through face-to-face meetings, meals, campus visits, calls, and events.
  • Learn what matters to each donor and create opportunities to experience Timothy’s mission firsthand.
  • Personally cultivate and solicit major gifts, with individualized strategies based on each donor’s interests, relationship, and capacity.
  • Build a sustainable pipeline—including families with affinity or capacity who have not yet been significant donors.
  • Lead relationship-based fundraising for capital campaigns, partnering with the Head of School, Board, and school leaders on key solicitations.

3. Planned Giving, Campaigns & Sponsorships

  • Develop Timothy’s planned and estate-giving program and steward legacy relationships over time.
  • Serve as fundraising relationship lead for Timothy Giving Day, the Golf Outing, Auction, and Taste of Timothy—owning philanthropic and sponsorship outcomes, not event logistics.
  • Identify, cultivate, solicit, and steward corporate and individual sponsors.

4. Stewardship, Loyalty & Advocacy

  • Personally steward significant donors so they understand Timothy’s gratitude and the impact of their generosity.
  • Recognize milestones, giving anniversaries, and life events with individualized stewardship.
  • Deepen relationships with Foundation members and help engaged supporters become ambassadors who open doors.
  • Maintain disciplined CRM records of conversations, interests, commitments, giving history, and next actions.
  • Use donor data and analytics to identify and prioritize prospects and uncover opportunities.
  • Collaborate across Advancement and report regularly to the Executive Director on pipeline, solicitations, and progress toward goals.
The Candidate: Who we’re looking for

Timothy seeks a mature Christian who genuinely enjoys people, listens first, and moves naturally from building a relationship to making a direct, personal invitation to give.

Spiritual Qualifications

  • Has received Jesus Christ as personal Savior and demonstrates a bold and active Christian faith.
  • Believes the Bible is God’s Word and the standard for faith and daily living.
  • Is in wholehearted agreement with Timothy’s Statement of Faith and Christian Philosophy of Education.
  • Is a Christian role model in attitude, speech, relationships, and actions toward others.
  • Is an active participant in an evangelical church.

Professional Qualifications

  • Exceptional interpersonal skills and genuine enjoyment of developing relationships.
  • Strong communication, especially in conversation, listening, storytelling, and persuasion.
  • Demonstrated comfort asking individuals to make significant financial commitments.
  • Discretion, integrity, emotional intelligence, confidentiality, and follow-through.
  • Familiarity with CRM systems and how donor data strengthens relationships.
  • Familiarity with Christian education and the Timothy community preferred.
  • Mission Alignment: Mature faith and wholehearted commitment to Timothy’s mission.
  • Mission Storyteller: Connects students, programs, and vision to donor interests.
  • Relationship Builder: Genuine curiosity about people and what matters to them.
  • Exceptional Listener: Seeks first to understand the donor, not to lead with a need.
  • Fundraising Acumen: Moves naturally from relationship to a direct, personal ask.
  • Strategic & Disciplined: Manages a portfolio intentionally and follows through.
  • Connector: Links donors to the people and priorities that deepen their bond.
  • Collaborative Partner: Works across teams while owning donor outcomes.
What Success Looks Like

Success is measured not simply by dollars raised, but by the strength of donor relationships, meaningful personal interactions, successful solicitations, increased generosity, a healthy pipeline of future donors, and long-term commitment to Timothy Christian Schools.

  • Growth and quality of the active major-donor portfolio
  • Meaningful personal and face-to-face donor interactions
  • Number and value of personal solicitations made
  • Major gifts, commitments, and increased giving secured
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Director of Donor Relations & Major Gifts
Director of Donor Relations & Major Gifts

Timothy Christian • Elmhurst (IL)

On-site
USD 110,000 - 180,000
Development Director
Development Director

TrulyHired • Louisville (KY)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Director of Advancement
Director of Advancement

HR Synergy • Moultonborough (NH)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 120,000
Associate Director, Major Gifts
Associate Director, Major Gifts

Gift of Life Marrow Registry • Boca Raton (FL)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Director of Development
Director of Development

Christian Leadership Alliance • United States

Remote
USD 90,000 - 150,000
Development Director
Development Director

Saint John Institute • United States

Remote
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Director of Development
Director of Development

Precept • Chattanooga (TN)

Remote
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Director of Development & Community Relations
Director of Development & Community Relations

EveryChild • Illinois

On-site
USD 55,000 - 65,000
Health insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+3
Director of Annual Giving
Director of Annual Giving

Palmer Theological Seminary of Eastern University • Saint Davids (PA)

Hybrid
USD 110,000 - 160,000
Director of Development
Director of Development

Tennis Outreach Programs • Kirkland (WA)

On-site
USD 150,000 - 190,000