Summary
The Commercial Review Appraiser independently reviews commercial real estate appraisals and evaluations to support safe, sound, and timely credit decisions. The role assesses valuation methodology, market support, assumptions, conclusions, and report compliance with bank policy, applicable appraisal regulations, and the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). The position also coordinates appraisal engagements, validates existing valuations when permitted, supports environmental due diligence, and provides objective valuation guidance to lending and credit partners while maintaining independence from loan production.
Specific Job Functions
- Perform independent technical and administrative reviews of commercial and residential real estate appraisals, evaluations, and related valuation products for completeness, reasonableness, credibility, and compliance.
- Assess highest and best use, property description, market and neighborhood analysis, comparable selection, adjustments, capitalization rates, discount rates, income and expense assumptions, reconciliation, and final value conclusions.
- Determine whether reports comply with USPAP, applicable federal appraisal requirements, internal appraisal policy, engagement instructions, and approved scope of work.
- Document review conclusions, material deficiencies, required corrections, risk considerations, and final disposition in a clear, supportable, and audit-ready manner.
- Communicate directly with appraisers and internal business partners to resolve questions or deficiencies without compromising appraisal independence.
- Coordinate the bidding, selection, engagement, tracking, and receipt of appraisal assignments, including review of requests for completeness and appropriate property-level scope.
- Confirm the appraiser or appraisal firm is appropriately licensed or certified, qualified for the assignment, independent, and included on the bank’s approved appraiser list.
- Review and validate existing appraisals or evaluations when permitted by policy, considering property, market, borrower, transaction, and timing changes.
- Order and review environmental due diligence reports, escalating recognized environmental conditions or other material concerns under established procedures.
- Provide valuation consultation to Credit Administration, Commercial Banking, Special Assets, Loan Operations, Internal Audit, and other control functions while preserving independent judgment.
- Monitor assignment pipelines, service-level expectations, exceptions, aging, and recurring quality issues; elevate significant delays or risk trends to management.
- Assist with maintenance of appraisal procedures, approved appraiser performance records, vendor due diligence, quality-control practices, and regulatory or audit responses.
- Perform other duties and special projects as assigned.
Minimum Job Requirements
- Bachelor’s degree in finance, accounting, business administration, or a related field is required.
- 1 - 3 years of experience as a commercial real estate appraiser is required.
- Certified General Real Estate Appraiser License in Texas or other applicable state is required.
- Prior banking experience is preferred.
- Demonstrated experience valuing or reviewing multiple commercial property types, such as office, retail, industrial, multifamily, hospitality, land, subdivisions, mixed-use, and special-purpose properties.
- Working knowledge of the sales comparison, income capitalization, and cost approaches, including discounted cash flow analysis when applicable.
- Knowledge of USPAP, appraisal independence requirements, bank appraisal and evaluation policy, and commercial real estate credit practices.
- Ability to analyze complex market data, identify unsupported assumptions, make defensible risk-based decisions, and communicate required corrections with precision.
- Advanced written communication, organization, prioritization, and stakeholder-management skills in a deadline-driven environment.
- Proficiency with Microsoft 365 applications is required.