Casualty Claims Supervisor

W. R. Berkley Corporation; Wilmington (DE); Hybrid; USD 90,000 - 130,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Competitive compensation

Paid time off

Wellness benefits

Health Savings Account

Profit sharing

401k

Paid parental leave

Employee stock purchase plan

Tuition assistance

Professional continuing education

Job summary

Berkley One in Wilmington, DE is seeking a Casualty Claims Supervisor to lead a team of adjusters and oversee the TPA network, ensuring high-quality service and strong risk management.

The role requires deep knowledge of auto, liability, and injury claims, plus proven leadership and collaboration with internal and external partners. Travel 5-10%, with competitive benefits and growth opportunities.

Qualifications

• Minimum 5 years of casualty claims management experience including auto, homeowner and injury claims.
• Minimum 3 years handling high-exposure and complex casualty claims.
• Strong understanding of insurance principles and effective communication with customers and partners.

Responsibilities

• Lead and develop the casualty claims team including adjusters and support staff.
• Oversee TPA operations and QA to ensure service quality.
• Manage auto, liability and injury claims end-to-end with focus on settlements and coverage reviews.
• Drive investigations, reserving, negotiation and timely resolution of complex claims.
• Coordinate with internal and external stakeholders and provide guidance on coverage determinations.

Skills

People leadership

Casualty claims

Auto claims

High-exposure claims

Analytical skills

Negotiation skills

Communication skills

Education

Bachelor’s degree or equivalent

Tools

CCC systems

ARMS

Copart

Job description

Company Details

Berkley Oneis a modern insurance provider for a modern generation of affluence. We serve clients who live dynamic, adventurous lives and expect their insurance experience to match. Our mission is to deliver highly personalized risk and claims management through a blend of expert independent agents, cutting-edge digital tools, and the strength of the Berkley brand.

Why Join Us?

At Berkley One, you will be part of a forward-thinking team that is reimagining personal insurance. We are building solutions that are as sophisticated and agile as the clients we serve, individuals and families who value innovation, simplicity, and exceptional service. You will collaborate with passionate professionals, leverage modern technology, and help shape the future of our industry.

#LI-AV1 #LI-HYBRID

What We Value

• A client-first mindset with a passion for delivering exceptional experiences
• Curiosity, creativity, and a drive to challenge the status quo
• Collaboration across disciplines to build smarter, more intuitive solutions
• Integrity, expertise, and a commitment to excellence

Join us in creating a new standard in personal insurance where protection meets possibility.

The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer.

Responsibilities

The Casualty Claims Supervisor is a key contributor to the Berkley One brand, supervising internal claims adjusters and overseeing Third-Party Administrator (TPA) operations and quality assurance. The role provides expert management and oversight of internal casualty claims adjusters and the TPA contracted network by managing processes, quality, and ensuring high-quality customer service.

What you can expect:

• Culture of innovation, teamwork, supportive colleagues and leaders willing to invest in talent
• Internal mobility opportunities
• Visibility to senior leaders and partnership with cross functional teams
• Opportunity to impact change
• Benefits – competitive compensation, paid time off, comprehensive wellness benefits and programs, employer funded health savings account, profit sharing, 401k, paid parental leave, employee stock purchase plan, tuition assistance and professional continuing education

We'll count on you to:

• Manage claims adjusters, support staff, and administrative personnel to meet or exceed performance metrics. Perform other duties as assigned.

• Manage, coach, and administer employee performance, compensation, and goal-setting processes for team members.

• Lead the adjustment and management of auto, liability, and injury claims, ensuring superior customer service to Berkley One customers, agent partners, and internal and external business partners.

• Provide direction and oversight for the adjustment of large or complex casualty claims.

• Conduct thorough investigations, assess damages, and oversee the entire claims process for the TPA network from end-to-end, including coverage reviews, reserving, negotiation, and settlement.

• Apply casualty claims expertise to make well-informed decisions and guide the effective resolution of claims.

• Analyze and interpret insurance coverage and clearly communicate positions in accordance with Berkley One guidelines and under the direction of the Casualty Claims Manager.

• Direct and manage assignments to external experts and legal counsel, ensuring efficiency and quality standards.

• Evaluate detailed information regarding coverage, liability, and damages, and ensure fair settlements within the confines of the policy contract.

• Set and adjust reserves within authority limits and recommend reserve changes as needed.

• Travel as necessary for business-related activities.

• Perform other duties as assigned.

Qualifications

What you need to have:

• Minimum of 5 years of experience in casualty claims management, including auto, homeowner, and injury claims.
• Minimum of 3 years of experience handling high-exposure and complex casualty claims.
• Demonstrated capability in handling complex coverage issues and a deep understanding of insurance and legal principles.
• Incredible empathy and understanding of the needs of customers, both insureds and their agents alike.
• Excellent analytical, decision-making, interpersonal, communication, and negotiation skills.
• Excellent, proactive advocacy for Berkley One customers and passion for their brand experience.
• Exceptional verbal and written communication skills, with a flexible communication style that adapts to the situation and the ability to communicate clearly and with purpose.
• Calm under pressure, with excellent organizational and negotiation skills, high integrity, and strong follow-through on tasks.
• Comfortable challenging norms while working collaboratively with colleagues at all levels of the organization.
• Strong sense of accountability, fun, and adventure.
• Natural curiosity, with a passion for continuous learning and looking for innovative improvements.
• Collaborative approach, coordinating with adjusters and managers on pending claim files requiring additional investigation and confirmation of coverage.
• Professional demeanor and ability to maintain composure in high-pressure situations.
• Ability to travel 5–10%

What makes you stand out:

• Bachelor’s degree or equivalent work experience
• People leadership experience is preferred
• Background in property claims management is a plus but not a prerequisite for this role
• TPA management experience, including management of contracts and practical application of service level agreements for quality assurance
• Proficiency with high-net-worth policy coverages and services
• Broad knowledge of CCC, ARMS, and Copart systems is preferred

Additional Company Details

We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.

Sponsorship Details

Sponsorship not Offered for this Role