Assistant Store Manager - Castile, NY

Reid Stores LLC; Village of Castile (NY); On-site; USD 42,000 - 54,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Company discounts

Paid Time Off

401K

Job summary

Reid Stores LLC is seeking an Assistant Store Manager to help lead Crosby’s-style daily store operations in New York. You will support the Team Leader in creating a clean, efficient, and welcoming environment while delivering exceptional customer service and driving store success.

You will supervise team members, maintain high standards, and ensure customers have a great experience—every day, every time. This is a full-time role requiring at least 40 hours per week, including weekends.

Qualifications

• Requires 21 years or older and a high school diploma or equivalent.
• Able to work at least 40 hours per week, including weekends.
• Valid driver’s license and reliable transportation per position requirements.
• Experience preferred; Serve Safe certified is a plus.

Responsibilities

• Assist with daily store operations and supervision of team members.
• Deliver friendly, professional customer service and resolve issues.
• Support cash handling, bank deposits, and payroll-related tasks.
• Coordinate scheduling and staffing levels; coach and develop staff.
• Maintain store cleanliness, safety, and brand standards.
• Oversee merchandising, promotions, and inventory activities.

Skills

Customer service

Team leadership

Cash handling

Basic math

POS proficiency

Scheduling

Staff coaching

Safety procedures

Identify verification

Education

High School Diploma or equivalent

Tools

POS system

Lottery/regs knowledge

Job description

Description

Crosby’s is looking for a motivated and dependable Assistant Store Manager to help lead daily store operations. In this role, you’ll support the Team Leader in creating a clean, efficient, and welcoming environment while delivering exceptional customer service and driving store success.

You’ll play a key role in supervising team members, maintaining high operational standards, and ensuring every customer has a great experience—every day, every time.

What You’ll Do

Customer Experience

• Deliver prompt, friendly, and professional service to every customer
• Prepare fresh food and made-to-order items following Crosby’s quality and cleanliness standards
• Promote and assist customers with enrolling in My Crosby’s Rewards
• Drive sales through suggestive selling and add-on recommendations
• Handle customer concerns and resolve issues when the Team Leader is not present

Store Operations

• Help oversee daily operations to ensure efficiency and profitability
• Maintain store cleanliness, organization, and brand standards
• Support merchandising, promotions, and inventory management
• Ensure compliance with all food safety, tobacco, alcohol, and company regulations
• Communicate effectively with team members and leadership

Team Leadership

• Train, coach, and support store associates
• Assist with scheduling and maintaining proper staffing levels
• Provide feedback on employee performance and development
• Foster a positive, respectful, and team-oriented work environment

Financial & Administrative

• Assist with inventory control, audits, and reporting
• Support accurate cash handling and daily bank deposits
• Review timekeeping and assist with payroll processing
• Report discrepancies and maintain accurate records

Safety & Maintenance

• Help maintain a safe and secure store environment
• Follow proper opening/closing procedures and cash security policies
• Monitor equipment, cleanliness, and overall store conditions
• Report maintenance or safety concerns promptly

*Benefits*

• Career growth opportunities - Whether you’re just starting out or looking to develop your career, we’ll help you grow.
• A culture of teamwork and support - Enjoy working with a close-knit team that celebrates each other’s successes.
• A chance to make an impact: Be part of a local brand that supports its community.

Career Growth Path: Sales Associate - Shift Leader - Assistant Team Leader - Team Leader

Benefits that matter:

• Company Discounts
• Significant Fuel Discounts!
• Paid Time Off
• 401K
• Referral Bonus ($250 + a free pizza!)
• Company-paid Employee Assistance Program

Requirements

Minimum Qualifications

• 21 years of age
• High School Diploma or equivalent
• Able to work at least 40 hours/week, including weekends
• Experience Preferred
• Valid Driver’s license that meets company policy
• Reliable transportation for position requirements (e.g., meetings, daily banking, etc.)
• Serve Safe certified, preferred
• Proficient in basic math to handle cash transactions, shift reports, and vendor check-ins
• Ability to clearly assess and validate customer identification
• Ability to understand operating instructions for lottery, point of sale systems (POS), and other equipment.
• Tolerance of exposure to gasoline fumes and cleaning products.

  The list of requirements, duties, and responsibilities is not exhaustive but is the most accurate list for the current job. Management reserves the right to revise the job outline and require other tasks to be performed when the circumstances of the job change (e.g., emergencies, changes in personnel, workload, or technical development.) This position description is not intended to imply a contract of employment. Employment with Reid Group is "at-will." Employment at-will may be terminated at any time by the employee or by Reid Group. All requirements and duties are considered essential functions. Reid Group also reserves the right to adjust workers' schedules and physical locations based on operational needs.