Annual Giving Manager

BHI Senior Living

Indianapolis (IN)

On-site

USD 60,000 - 90,000

Full time

25 hours ago
Be an early applicant

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

401k match up to 5%
Employer-paid life insurance
PTO from day one
Paid holidays
Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
Student loan repayment and tuition aid

Job summary

BHI Senior Living is seeking an Annual Giving Manager to inspire generosity and build donor relationships across six Indiana communities. From creating compelling campaigns to growing recurring giving and showing donors the impact of their support, you’ll help turn first-time gifts into lasting philanthropic connections.

Your creativity, relationship-building skills, and ability to translate data into action will strengthen annual giving and support our mission.

Qualifications

  • Bachelor’s degree in fundraising, communications, marketing, business, nonprofit management, or a related field.
  • 3–5 years of annual giving, fundraising, nonprofit marketing, donor relations, or related field.
  • Experience planning and executing direct response fundraising campaigns, including direct mail and digital appeals.
  • Experience using donor relationship management systems.
  • Strong written communication and ability to translate data into action.
  • Ability to collaborate across teams while maintaining confidentiality.
  • CFRE credential preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Develop and implement the Foundation's annual fundraising strategy across six Indiana communities.
  • Create campaign themes, messaging, and multichannel calendars for all communities.
  • Collaborate with Operations to evaluate goals and KPIs for improvements.
  • Manage donor communications, stewardship journeys, and donor reporting.
  • Support Major Gifts team in transitioning prospects as needed.
  • Maintain donor portfolios and ensure timely reporting.

Job description

The mission of BHI Senior Living Inc. is to enhance the quality of life for older adults within a secure environment that supports their needs, values, interests, and independence while encouraging personal and spiritual development. BHI is an organization deeply committed to doing what’s right for the people we serve and those we employ.


The BHI Foundation exists to enrich the lives of older adults across every BHI Senior Living community. Through the generosity of donors, we provide benevolent care for residents in need, support for dedicated employees, and meaningful enrichment programs that bring joy, connection, and purpose to daily life. Our communities are more than just a place to live- they’re places to thrive. With the support of our donors, we make it possible to offer a wide range of programs, experiences, and spaces that bring purpose, creativity, and joy to every stage of life.


As an Annual Giving Manager, you’ll inspire generosity and build meaningful donor relationships across BHI Foundation’s six Indiana communities. From creating compelling fundraising campaigns to growing recurring giving and showing donors the impact of their support, you’ll help turn first-time gifts into lasting philanthropic connections. Your creativity, relationship-building skills, and ability to translate data into action will strengthen annual giving and support our mission of enriching the lives of older adults.


At BHI Senior Living, we are united in mission, lead with compassion, and provide opportunities to grow and thrive professionally.


Why You’ll Love Working Here:

Robust benefits including 401k match (up to 5%), medical, dental and vision insurance


Employer-paid life insurance


PTO (paid time off) earned from day one of employment


Paid holidays


Access to Employee Assistance Program (EAP)


Student loan repayment and tuition assistance


What You Will Do:

Annual Giving Strategy & Campaign Management


  • Develop and implement the Foundation's annual fundraising strategy across six Indiana communities.

  • Develop annual campaign themes, messaging strategies, and multichannel fundraising calendars and coordinate campaign schedules across all communities.

  • Collaborate with the BHI Foundation Operations team to evaluate goals and KPIs to inform further development and campaign improvements.

  • Evaluate each campaign on a community-by-community basis, report results and impact to Foundation Leadership and Community Executive Directors, and recommend adjustments to each appeal as appropriate.


Direct Mail & Marketing Communications


  • Plan and execute all direct mail campaigns from concept through production.

  • Partner with the Foundation Operations team to develop andmaintaindonor mailing lists, audience segmentation, and campaign data to support targeted fundraising initiatives.

  • Maintain a donor portfolio of annual donors while soliciting gifts up to $10,000

  • Support the BHI Foundation Major Gifts team to transition qualified Major gift prospects to the appropriate Community Major Gifts Officer


Stewardship & Donor Experience


  • Develop stewardship journeys for one time and recurring donors that strengthen donor loyalty, increase retention, and encourage recurring philanthropy.

  • Create impact reports and stewardship communications.


Who You Are

Bachelor’s degree in fundraising, communications, marketing, business, nonprofit management, or a related field.


Three to five years of experience in annual giving, fundraising, nonprofit marketing, donor relations, or a related field.


Experience planning and executing direct response fundraising campaigns, including direct mail and digital appeals.


Experience using donor relationship management systems.


Strong written communication skills, including the ability to develop compelling, donor-centered fundraising messages.


Demonstrated project management skills, with the ability to manage multiple campaigns, deadlines, and priorities simultaneously.


Strong analytical skills and the ability to interpret fundraising performance data to guide decisions and improve results.


Excellent interpersonal, relationship-building, organizational, and communication skills.


Ability to collaborate across teams and communities while exercising independent judgment and maintaining confidentiality.


Preferred:

Certified Fund Raising Executive (CFRE) credential.


Familiarity with Blackbaud Raiser’s Edge NXT.


Experience with fundraising analytics, donor segmentation, campaign testing, and performance measurement.


Experience in senior living, healthcare, or other mission-driven nonprofit organizations.


Familiarity with digital fundraising platforms, online giving tools, and donor engagement technologies.


BHI Senior Living is an equal opportunity employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, age, sex, national origin, disability status, genetics, protected veteran status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state, or local laws.


Equal Opportunity Employer

This employer is required to notify all applicants of their rights pursuant to federal employment laws.For further information, please review the Know Your Rights notice from the Department of Labor.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Director of Development
Director of Development

BHI Senior Living • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 130,000
401k match
Employer-paid life insurance
PTO from day one
+3
Development Director
Development Director

BHI Senior Living • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 120,000
401k match
Medical, dental and vision insurance
Employer-paid life Insurance
+5
Executive Assistant
Executive Assistant

BHI Senior Living • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 50,000 - 70,000
401k match up to 5%
Medical, dental and vision insurance
Employer-paid life insurance
+4
Annual Giving Manager: Grow Donor Impact Across Indiana
Annual Giving Manager: Grow Donor Impact Across Indiana

BHI Senior Living • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
401k match up to 5%
Employer-paid life insurance
PTO from day one
+3
Annual Fund Manager
Annual Fund Manager

Indyhunger • Carmel (IN)

On-site
USD 65,000 - 90,000
Annual Campaign & Donor Stewardship Manager
Annual Campaign & Donor Stewardship Manager

Central Health • Austin (TX)

Hybrid
USD 85,000 - 125,000
Vice President, Development
Vice President, Development

Black Women's Health Imperative • Washington, Atlanta (GA)

Hybrid
USD 120,000 - 140,000
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives

BMC Software, Inc. • Boston (MA)

On-site
USD 122,000 - 177,000
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives

Boston Medical Center • Boston (MA)

On-site
USD 122,000 - 177,000
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives
Director, Annual & Community Giving Initiatives

Boston Medical Center • Boston (MA)

On-site
USD 122,000 - 177,000